Your calorie deficit is the difference between your daily energy needs and what you eat. To calculate it, multiply your basal metabolic rate by your activity factor to get your needs, then subtract 300 to 600 kcal. The German S3 obesity guideline recommends about 500 to 600 kcal per day. At first, that is roughly 0.5 kg (1 lb) per week. You will often read that 3,500 calories equal a pound of fat, or about 7,700 per kilogram. As a starting point, that works. Over weeks and months, though, the math fits less and less, and that is exactly when many people start wondering what they are doing wrong. Here we calculate your deficit step by step and then look at where the math reaches its limits. The studies are linked at the end.
How to calculate your calorie deficit
You need three numbers: your basal metabolic rate, your activity factor and the deficit you are aiming for.
Basal metabolic rate. This is what you burn at rest. The most widely used formula is Mifflin-St Jeor, which usually performs best in comparison studies:
Women: 10 × weight (kg) + 6.25 × height (cm) − 5 × age − 161
Men: 10 × weight (kg) + 6.25 × height (cm) − 5 × age + 5
Activity factor. Multiply your basal metabolic rate by this factor:
| Daily life | Factor |
|---|---|
| Sedentary, little movement | 1.2 |
| Lightly active (desk job, 1 to 3 workouts per week) | 1.375 |
| Moderately active (3 to 5 workouts per week) | 1.55 |
| Very active (6 to 7 workouts per week) | 1.725 |
| Extremely active (physical job plus training) | 1.9 |
If in doubt, pick the lower value. Most people rate themselves as more active than they are.
Deficit. Subtract your deficit from the result, usually 300 to 600 kcal. Which value suits you is covered further down.
An example: Anna is 34, 1.68 m (5'6") tall, weighs 82 kg (181 lb), works in an office and trains twice a week. Her basal metabolic rate is 1,539 kcal (10 × 82 + 6.25 × 168 − 5 × 34 − 161). With a factor of 1.375 she needs about 2,100 kcal a day. With a 500 kcal deficit, she eats about 1,600 kcal.
If you would rather not do the math yourself, use our calorie calculator.
Free tool
Calorie calculator
BMR, total daily energy expenditure and your target in 30 seconds. No sign-up.
How accurate is the result?
Less accurate than the number on the screen suggests. Formulas describe the average of many people, and for any one person they are often well off.
In a meta-analysis of 61 studies in people with overweight, even the most precise formula landed within 10% of measured resting energy expenditure for only 61 to 63% of participants (Macena et al., 2022). In athletes it was mostly 41 to 64%, depending on the formula (O'Neill et al., 2023).
For Anna, that means her needs could be 1,900 or 2,330 kcal instead of 2,100. That range is almost half the size of her planned deficit. If she does not lose weight on 1,600 kcal after a few weeks, it is not necessarily her fault.
Exercise also counts for less in everyday life than your watch shows. In an analysis of 1,754 measurements with doubly labeled water, on average only 72% of the extra calories burned actually showed up in total daily energy expenditure (Careau et al., 2021). The body saves the rest elsewhere.
So treat your result as a starting value. Further down you will find how to work out your actual needs.
How big should your calorie deficit be?
The German S3 guideline on the treatment of obesity, developed with the German Nutrition Society (DGE) among others, recommends a daily energy deficit of about 500 to 600 kcal, or alternatively an individually determined deficit (German Obesity Society, 2024). The recommendation is based on expert consensus and is aimed at adults with obesity.
If you are at a normal weight and train, a smaller deficit often works better:
| Starting point | Deficit | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Clearly overweight | 500 to 600 kcal per day | S3 guideline. Losing weight faster is not automatically worse here, but it should be done with medical supervision. |
| Normal weight, strength training, keeping muscle | up to about 500 kcal per day, or 0.5 to 0.7% of body weight per week | From a deficit of about 500 kcal, gains in lean mass stopped in a meta-regression, while strength gains did not (Murphy & Koehler, 2022). Elite athletes who lost 0.7% per week even built a little muscle (Garthe et al., 2011). |
| Already fairly lean | closer to 0.5% of body weight per week | The less body fat you have, the more likely you are to lose muscle when you lose weight quickly (Helms et al., 2014). |
For Anna at 82 kg, 0.5 to 0.7% per week would be about 0.4 to 0.6 kg. That fits her 500 kcal.
There is a lower limit. The S3 guideline describes weight-loss diets as 1,200 to 2,000 kcal per day. Below that, between 800 and 1,200 kcal, are very low calorie diets, which should be medically supervised. That is why our calorie calculator does not go below 1,200 kcal for women and 1,500 kcal for men.
It is often said that losing weight slowly protects you from the yo-yo effect. In people with obesity, that could not be shown: in a study with 200 participants, both groups had regained a similar amount after almost three years, 71.2% after fast and 70.5% after slow weight loss (Purcell et al., 2014). The pace matters more for lean people who train, because they are more likely to lose muscle if they lose weight too quickly.
What the 3,500-calorie rule leaves out
According to this rule, a 500 kcal daily deficit brings a pound (about 0.5 kg) per week, steadily for a whole year. That is not how it works in practice (Thomas et al., 2013).
In the first weeks, weight often drops faster than expected. Part of that is water: the body stores carbohydrates as glycogen, and every gram of it binds three to four grams of water (Kreitzman et al., 1992). A kilogram lost early on therefore contained only about 4,900 kcal on average, far less than the rule assumes (Heymsfield et al., 2012).
Later it slows down, because a lighter body burns less. Your deficit shrinks with every kilogram, even if you keep eating the same amount. Kevin Hall of the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) developed a model for this. As a rule of thumb, every lasting change of about 22 to 24 kcal per day changes your weight by around 1 kg in the long run. You reach half of that after about a year and 95% after about three years (Hall et al., 2011).
For Anna, who permanently eats 500 kcal less than before, this leads to very different expectations:
| Calculation | After 12 months |
|---|---|
| 3,500-calorie rule | about 24 kg (52 lb) |
| Hall model (2011), if she sticks to it exactly | about 10 to 11 kg (21 to 23 kg in the long run) |
| What the S3 guideline expects in everyday life | 5 to 6 kg |
The guideline also notes that half a kilogram per week can only be expected for up to three months, and that a new balance usually sets in after three to six months. If your progress slows down after a few months, that is normal.
Finding your actual energy needs
Your own weight trend is more accurate than any formula. You need about three weeks for it.
During this time, eat roughly the same amount every day, for example the value from the calculator. Log everything, including oil, drinks and snacks. That is the hardest part: in a large study, women under-reported what they ate by 16 to 20% even when questioned carefully (Subar et al., 2003).
Weigh yourself every morning at the same time, after using the bathroom and before breakfast, and take the average for each week. The first week does not count, because your water balance needs time to settle after a change. Then compare weeks 2 and 3:
If your weight stays about the same (±0.2 kg), your intake roughly matches your needs.
If it drops by 0.3 kg per week, your needs are roughly 300 kcal above what you eat (0.3 kg × about 7,700 kcal ÷ 7 days).
If it goes up, your needs are below what you eat.
Over such a short period, this calculation is accurate enough. If you have a menstrual cycle, compare weeks in the same phase of your cycle or give yourself four weeks.
Plan your deficit from this value. After you have lost a few kilograms, it is worth repeating the test, because your needs drop as your weight drops.
Why the scale sometimes won't move
If you eat in a deficit and your weight still stays the same for days, one of these causes is usually behind it.
Water. Even in a normal week, weight fluctuates by about 0.35%, and it is usually higher after the weekend (Turicchi et al., 2020). For Anna that is almost 300 grams, more than the fat she loses in a week. Salty or carb-heavy meals and unfamiliar training make the body hold extra water. Many women also notice water retention around their period, strongest on the first day (White et al., 2011).
Logging. Almost everyone underestimates how much they eat. On top of that, nutrition labels show average values. Under EU guidance, for example, protein, carbohydrates and fat in the range of 10 to 40 g per 100 g may deviate from the declared value by 20% (European Commission, 2012). The calories on the package can be noticeably off.
Exercise. As described above, on average only about 72% of extra calories burned actually count. If you eat back everything your watch says you burned, you are often no longer in a deficit.
So look at the trend over two to three weeks rather than at single days. There is no dedicated study on this, but it follows from the known fluctuations.
Does dieting slow down your metabolism?
A little, but less than is often claimed. Your energy expenditure drops mainly because you get lighter. On top of that there is a small additional adjustment called adaptive thermogenesis.
In a study of 171 women who had lost 12 kg on average, this additional adjustment was around 54 kcal per day, measured after four weeks at a stable weight. It did not predict who regained weight later (Martins et al., 2020). A review of 33 studies comes to a similar conclusion: the more carefully it was measured, the smaller the effect, or it could not be detected at all (Nunes et al., 2022).
A study of contestants from the TV show "The Biggest Loser" is often cited. Six years later, their adjustment was still around 500 kcal per day (Fothergill et al., 2016). However, these were only 14 people who had lost 58 kg on average under extreme conditions. That does not translate to a normal diet.
Hunger has a stronger effect than metabolism. One analysis estimates that appetite increases by about 100 kcal per day for every kilogram lost, more than three times as much as energy expenditure drops (Polidori et al., 2016). When weight loss stalls or weight comes back, appetite is therefore usually more to blame than metabolism. Meals that keep you full for a long time matter just as much as the calorie count.
Fat or muscle: what you lose
With the same deficit, you can lose very different amounts of fat and muscle. These four things make a difference.
Protein. More protein than the basic recommendation of 0.8 g per kilogram of body weight protects muscle in a deficit. In a meta-analysis, people with a higher intake lost on average 0.36 kg less lean mass during a diet (Hudson et al., 2020). For building muscle with strength training, the benefit increased up to about 1.6 g per kilogram and barely beyond that (Morton et al., 2018). In a deficit, about 1.6 g per kilogram is a good guideline, a bit more for lean strength athletes. If you are clearly overweight, use your goal weight. Protein also keeps you full.
Strength training. In an analysis of 34 studies, exercise during a diet prevented on average 45.7% of the loss of lean mass, almost half. Strength and combined training did best (Deller et al., 2026).
Sleep. In a lab study with ten people, everyone ate with the same deficit for two weeks, once with 8.5 and once with 5.5 hours of sleep. With little sleep they lost 55% less fat and 60% more lean mass, and they were hungrier (Nedeltcheva et al., 2010). An eight-week study came to a similar result (Wang et al., 2018). Both studies are small, but the direction is clear.
Minimally processed food. On a highly processed diet, people in one trial ate around 500 kcal more per day without noticing (Hall et al., 2019). In a British study from 2025, participants on minimally processed food lost twice as much weight in eight weeks as on highly processed food, even though both menus followed official dietary guidelines (−2.06% versus −1.05% of body weight; Dicken et al., 2025).
The same applies to weight loss with medication. A review of 35 studies found that with both weight-loss injections and diets, often a quarter or more of the weight lost is lean mass, 28% at the median (Batsis et al., 2026). Protein and strength training make sense in both cases.
Diet breaks and intermittent fasting
With the same deficit, neither method leads to more fat loss. A meta-analysis of 28 studies found no difference in fat loss between intermittent fasting and a steady deficit, and intermittent fasting tended to cost slightly more lean mass (Schroor et al., 2024).
Planned diet breaks, for example three weeks in a deficit and one week at maintenance, did not bring more fat loss in trained people either. But participants were less hungry and coped better (Peos et al., 2021). An older study in men with obesity had found an advantage for the breaks (Byrne et al., 2018), which the later study did not confirm.
So what matters is which approach you can keep up for months. If breaks help you do that, there is nothing against them.
How fytrr helps
You can do the three-week test with pen and paper. In fytrr, you take a photo of your meal and get a calorie estimate. Your workout and meal plans are built to fit together, so protein and strength training are already planned in. And Mona, your coach in the app, swaps meals when something doesn't suit you.
fytrr also starts with an estimate. Your weight trend over the first few weeks shows whether it fits you.

Written by
Tobias LobitzFounder & Software Developer. Developing fitness software since 2018. Personal training experience: 15 years of strength training.
Expert reviewed by
Felipe H.
Sports scientist (B.Sc.), M.Sc. student in sports science, Essen. Reviewed on November 11, 2026.
Last updated on November 14, 2026
